Logger wants 40% split, should I just buy a tractor and DIY?

[Frednot]

Got a logger lined up for my 8 acres but he's asking for a 40/60 split and with my 60%, I still have to cover taxes, replanting, and all the brush cleanup. Looking at used tractors and they're running $15k to 20k minimum or thereabout for anything decent. The tractor dealer keeps saying I'd save money doing it myself, plus I'd have equipment for other farm work. But I'm wondering if I'm just inexperienced and this is one of those "what you don't know can kill you" situations.
Is the 40% worth it for someone who actually knows what they're doing, or are loggers overpaid for work I could realistically learn? how long does it actually take to get competent at this?

 

[lgf3rr]

That 40% pays for the safety, insurance, specialized equipment, market access, and expertise you don't have. The tractor dealer is selling tractors, not logging wisdom. A $15-20k tractor isn't a logging setup. You'd need a winch, heavy-duty chainsaws, proper safety gear, and the skill to use them, which adds up to much more money and years of training. Logging is one of the most dangerous jobs out there, so for 8 acres, I think the 40% split for a fully insured professional is worth it. But for your peace of mind, you can try getting a couple more bids on the split!

 

[What]

That is actually a good deal. Last few jobs I've done, I charged half.

 

[Alan]

Ooh this is a big one, I'd tread carefully here. The tractor dealer has a vested interest in selling you a tractor, just saying lol but I'll let the folks with actual logging experience weigh in

 

[cjmac163]

Ooh this is a big one, I'd tread carefully here. The tractor dealer has a vested interest in selling you a tractor, just saying lol but I'll let the folks with actual logging experience weigh in

Great point! Ha! Thanks for the chuckle, Alan

 

[What]

I just wrapped up logging 80 acres for a guy, 50/50 split, so if he will do it for only 40%, seems like a no brainer to hire him.